How Good Is The Domain Name Business?

Are you considering becoming a top-level-domain name registry?

If you are a potential applicant for a new top level domain name you may be asking yourself or your staff, “How good is the domain name business?” or “Should we be involved in a new top level domain?”  I’ve been in the business for over 10 years and I admit that I ask myself this same question each year, just as part of my professional self assessment.  I must say, that I always come back with the decision to stay in this business.  Here are some reasons why:

Profitability: Although profit margins on most domain names are squeezed because of competition, it is a “transactional sale”.  This means that, as long as you keep the processes automated (which is generally easy to do in the domain name business), any amount of net profit is high because the cost of provisioning the product is so low.

This formula changes if you are operating a sponsored or restricted registry because there is a cost involved in verification (making sure that a registrant qualifies for the domain name). But certainly the process of verification can be automated in many ways as well.

Predictability: One of the most valuable aspects of the domain name business is that once registrants choose a domain they tend to keep it.  Renewal rates in the industry are in the realm of 60% to 85%. This allows for business predictability and steady growth.  In effect, the success of your customer’s businesses (and/or hobbies or personal interests) are directly tied to your domain business and because renewal rates are predictable, this ensures much easier business planning.

Business Risk: The domain name industry is digital.  You are selling digital assets that have plenty of upside and really no risk of loss. If you are defrauded by credit card fraud, you just cancel the domain. You’ve not borne the cost of shipping, you’ve not lost any physical goods, and you completely control the asset (as a registry).  It is painful to see how many businesses that ship physical goods nationally and internationally, lose their shirts on fraud or mistakes.  The domain name business carries none of this kind of loss potential.

Repeat / Cross-Selling Opportunities: Almost every business and/or non-profit, or organization in the world needs a web site today.  This has become a fact of life.  A web site is often the most practical and basic need in business communications.  In fact, it is often one of the first things that a company does when opening its doors.  A domain name registry (or registrar) has access to businesses from the moment of their inception so it is a grand entree` for other business services.  Most domain name registrars also offer web hosting, merchant accounts, privacy settings, directory listings, marketing services, etc.  The potential for upgrades and additional business services offered to domain name registrants is limited only by your imagination.

Growth Potential: When I started in the industry, I couldn’t believe it when we passed the million-domain-names-registered mark.  Today, according to Verisign’s Domain Name Brief, the industry is at 215 million domain names registered across all top level domains.  Most experts believe that this is just the beginning.  Certainly, the Internet is being exploited as a medium, but from a business standpoint (businesses using the Internet as a channel for communication and sales) it is only just beginning.  I have no doubt that as more and more businesses and individuals find uses for the Internet, that these numbers will double.

New top level domain names will open up several opportunities for companies and individuals world-wide and it will become easier for an entity to find a practical domain name that they identify with because there will be so many more choices.  I don’t buy the idea that the Internet will become confusing because of these new choices.  If the Internet existed when I was in second grade, I would have been able to tell the difference between ford.com, ford.car, and even car.ford. It’s basic second grade reading; not that complicated.  Internet users will be able to tell the difference and understand the choices. Services will be provided to assist people in finding their way around.

Stability: Many businesses are cyclical and dependent on the economy and business cycles.  Think real estate or retail.  They are often also dependent on locales.  California & Nevada have been especially hard hit by the recession; The Internet is global in nature and thus, more resistant to local and national business cycles.  It has it’s ups and downs, booms and busts, but overall has continued to grow.

Security: Just like we still use physical addresses to identify the locations of our homes and businesses in the 21st century, we will need virtual addresses to identify our virtual locations for the foreseeable future.  This need should be a staple for many years to come and domain names are at the very heart of this system.

The Domain Name System was born out of a very human attribute, we remember names easier than we do numbers. That attribute seems very unlikely to change.  Staking your claim in the virtual world via the domain name industry (or a new Top Level Domain) seems to be a safe bet on the future, assuming you choose and win a TLD with a market behind it.

Competition: A domain name registry is a natural monopoly.  Although registrants can register other names and other endings, if they want your ending bad enough, you are the only place they can get it.  And there is still a ton of growth waiting to happen in the e-commerce world.

Disclaimer: This article is not meant to be a sales pitch of any kind. It is not meant to advocate or oppose your decision about whether to invest in a new TLD.  I only mean to share my thoughts and observations of this industry as compared to others and give you my insight.  Running a domain name registry is a challenge and if you are going to get involved, you’d better be prepared with a good idea and a strong market.  But if you think you have those things, I can’t think of a better industry to be involved in.  In fact, the points I’ve made here are only some of the positive aspects.  There are many more.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on How Good Is The Domain Name Business?

New Top Level Domain (TLD) Experts Speak Out

CentralNic’s CEO, Ben Crawford, recently appeared on an informational video put out by ICANN.  Most of these, are people who have been involved in the domain name space for many years and who’ve played a part in the history and growth of the domain names space.

The video features registry experts from across the board:

  •     Ben Crawford, CentralNic
  •     Brian Cute, PIR
  •     Karim Jiwani, .Pro
  •     Ken Hansen, Neustar
  •     Nacho Amadaz, .CAT
  •     Pat Kane, Verisign
  •     Pinky Brand, .Mobi
  •     Robert LaPlante, Afilias

New Top Level Domains (TLDs) represent the most significant change to the Internet since it’s inception. This is not the first time that new TLDs have been allowed but it is the first time that they have been allowed on this scale.

I don’t like to “hype” things but there is a certain urgency to making decisions on top level domains today.  Any brand with a significant ad spend needs to pay attention.  Entrepreneurs who want to build significant, predictable businesses need to pay attention.  And association executives, who represent significant communities in almost any large vertical market, need to pay attention.

I participated in a webinar yesterday, put on by one of the world’s most respected international law and business advisory firms, Steptoe & Johnson, LLP.  They are recommending that applicants have their strategy in place by Octover 31, 2010.  They also suggested that the decision to apply for a new TLD be made at the highest levels within a corporation/entity.

If you’d like more information, please contact me.  For a more lengthy presentation on new TLDs, you may also want to view the ICANN panel below which occurred earlier this month in London.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on New Top Level Domain (TLD) Experts Speak Out

The Single Word that is Stealing Your Future

I loved this short inspirational text from American author, Robert Bruce…

You can talk all you want about what you’ll write Tomorrow, next week, and next year.
It matters very little.
Tomorrow and next week and next year are not yours to spend.
You can talk all you want about what you’ll build Tomorrow, next week, and next year.
You’d be an arrogant liar.

Tomorrow and next week and next year are not yours to plan.
You do not see your life as the vapor that it is  –
how your hours curl up and away from that hot, black coffee on the table,
dissipating faster than they appeared.

If you intend to write something, write it.
If you intend to build something, build it.

Each time you file that blank page away  –  to finish it Tomorrow  –
Tomorrow reaches deep into your wallet and takes exactly what it wants.

Tomorrow is a master thief, patiently waiting for you to lay down the pen.
To walk away from the page.

Today is not always sexy.
Today does not always feel comfortable.
Today has many demands, but …
Today is all you’ve been given. And you can build everything you want and need with it.

So what are you going to do today?

About the Author: Robert Bruce is an American writer and amateur recluse.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on The Single Word that is Stealing Your Future

What Can You NOT Get in a New TLD?

Although there are many ideas being floated about what new Top Level Domains can be created.  There may not be enough articles explicitly showing what cannot be created because they already exist or are reserved names that won’t be able to be issued because of the rules.  Amongst the many rules put forth by ICANN for new TLDs, one of the most basic ones is that a new top level domain must not be the same as an existing top level domain (or even too similar).

I’ve seen several different figures about how many top level domains exist today. My count from perusing ICANN’s site is 284.  But then there are at least 34 “reserved names” which means that any new registry will have to prevent at least these 34 strings from being issued. I don’t think you’ll be seeing anyone getting these strings to the right of the dot as well.  That means that in their most basic forms, there are at least 318 existing strings that you will surely not be able to get as a new top level domain.

An interesting (hypothetical) example could be GM.  General Motors is not going to be able to get GM.COM (that is assuming they want a new TLD and they have not publicly indicated that they do; I’m just using this as an example).  .GM is already allocated to the country of Gambia.  Now that doesn’t mean GM can’t pay the government of Gambia to let them use .GM.  Many ccTLDs are already being used for reasons different than their original intent because of agreements with governments (e.g. .tv, .fm, .me…).  Since GM’s gross revenues are 30 times that of Gambia’s GDP, it would seem that they could to cut a deal if both parties wanted to. Who knows?  Maybe it would be cheaper for them that way :-). But GM is not getting .GM any other way.

On top of the stated problem, new TLDs have to be at least 3 letters in length.  (Note: The longest they can be is 63 characters and they cannot include numbers). So maybe they can get .GMC?

Even that could be problematic since it is very close to .GM.  Only time will tell how these things will go.  For a while, a company that contracted with ICANN had a TLD string analyzer online where they claimed you could get some idea of how close two strings of characters were and if they were too close to be considered using an algorithm they developed.  Unfortunately, as of this writing, the web page hasn’t worked for several weeks and I’m not sure if it ever will.  This was the address.  Hopefully it will begin to work again soon: http://icann.sword-group.com/algorithm/Default.aspx

So that all said, below is my list of the TLDs that are “already taken” and that will have to be considered in any application made.

I apologize to my ICANN associates if some of this seems elementary, but condensed lists like this are helpful to me and, I think, to others that don’t dwell in this industry on a day-to-day basis.

Feel free to use this list to match up against your ideas.  Remember that this is not an official listing; just my personal research.  I list these here just for convenience. I apologize and take no responsibility for any errors or omissions:

EXISTING/ |   TYPE  |   COUNTRY
RESERVED  |  TLD     |   REPRESENTED (IF APPLICABLE)

.COM        Generic
.INFO        Generic
.NET        Generic
.ORG        Generic
.BIZ        Generic-Restricted
.NAME        Generic-Restricted
.PRO        Generic-Restricted
.AERO        Sponsored
.ASIA        Sponsored
.CAT        Sponsored
.COOP        Sponsored
.EDU        Sponsored
.GOV        Sponsored
.INT        Sponsored
.JOBS        Sponsored
.MIL        Sponsored
.MOBI        Sponsored
.MUSEUM        Sponsored
.TEL        Sponsored
.TRAVEL        Sponsored
.ARPA        Infrastructure

.AC        Country-Code    Ascension Island
.AD        Country-Code    Andorra
.AE        Country-Code    United Arab Emirates
.AF        Country-Code    Afghanistan
.AG        Country-Code    Antigua and Barbuda
.AI        Country-Code    Anguilla
.AL        Country-Code    Albania
.AM        Country-Code    Armenia
.AN        Country-Code    Netherlands Antilles
.AO        Country-Code    Angola
.AQ        Country-Code    Antarctica
.AR        Country-Code    Argentina
.AS        Country-Code    American Samoa AS Domain Registry
.AT        Country-Code    Austria
.AU        Country-Code    Australia
.AW        Country-Code    Aruba
.AX        Country-Code    Aland Islands
.AZ        Country-Code    Azerbaijan
.BA        Country-Code    Bosnia and Herzegovina
.BB        Country-Code    Barbados
.BD        Country-Code    Bangladesh
.BE        Country-Code    Belgium
.BF        Country-Code    Burkina Faso
.BG        Country-Code    Bulgaria
.BH        Country-Code    Bahrain
.BI        Country-Code    Burundi
.BJ        Country-Code    Benin
.BL        Country-Code    Saint Barthelemy
.BM        Country-Code    Bermuda
.BN        Country-Code    Brunei Darussalam
.BO        Country-Code    Bolivia
.BR        Country-Code    Brazil
.BS        Country-Code    Bahamas
.BT        Country-Code    Bhutan
.BV        Country-Code    Bouvet Island
.BW        Country-Code    Botswana
.BY        Country-Code    Belarus
.BZ        Country-Code    Belize
.CA        Country-Code    Canada
.CC        Country-Code    Cocos (Keeling) Islands
.CD        Country-Code    Congo, The Democratic Republic of the
.CF        Country-Code    Central African Republic
.CG        Country-Code    Congo
.CH        Country-Code    Switzerland
.CI        Country-Code    Cote d’Ivoire
.CK        Country-Code    Cook Islands
.CL        Country-Code    Chile
.CM        Country-Code    Cameroon
.CN        Country-Code    China
.CO        Country-Code    Colombia
.CR        Country-Code    Costa Rica
.CU        Country-Code    Cuba
.CV        Country-Code    Cape Verde
.CX        Country-Code    Christmas Island
.CY        Country-Code    Cyprus
.CZ        Country-Code    Czech Republic
.DE        Country-Code    Germany
.DJ        Country-Code    Djibouti
.DK        Country-Code    Denmark
.DM        Country-Code    Dominica
.DO        Country-Code    Dominican Republic
.DZ        Country-Code    Algeria
.EC        Country-Code    Ecuador
.EE        Country-Code    Estonia
.EG        Country-Code    Egypt
.EH        Country-Code    Western Sahara
.ER        Country-Code    Eritrea
.ES        Country-Code    Spain
.ET        Country-Code    Ethiopia
.EU        Country-Code    European Union
.FI        Country-Code    Finland
.FJ        Country-Code    Fiji
.FK        Country-Code    Falkland Islands (Malvinas)
.FM        Country-Code    Micronesia, Federated States of
.FO        Country-Code    Faroe Islands
.FR        Country-Code    France
.GA        Country-Code    Gabon
.GB        Country-Code    United Kingdom
.GD        Country-Code    Grenada
.GE        Country-Code    Georgia
.GF        Country-Code    French Guiana
.GG        Country-Code    Guernsey
.GH        Country-Code    Ghana
.GI        Country-Code    Gibraltar
.GL        Country-Code    Greenland
.GM        Country-Code    Gambia
.GN        Country-Code    Guinea
.GP        Country-Code    Guadeloupe
.GQ        Country-Code    Equatorial Guinea
.GR        Country-Code    Greece
.GS        Country-Code    South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands
.GT        Country-Code    Guatemala
.GU        Country-Code    Guam
.GW        Country-Code    Guinea
.GY        Country-Code    Guyana
.HK        Country-Code    Hong Kong
.HM        Country-Code    Heard Island and McDonald Islands
.HN        Country-Code    Honduras
.HR        Country-Code    Croatia
.HT        Country-Code    Haiti
.HU        Country-Code    Hungary
.ID        Country-Code    Indonesia
.IE        Country-Code    Ireland
.IL        Country-Code    Israel
.IM        Country-Code    Isle of Man
.IN        Country-Code    India
.IO        Country-Code    British Indian Ocean Territory
.IQ        Country-Code    Iraq
.IR        Country-Code    Iran, Islamic Republic of
.IS        Country-Code    Iceland
.IT        Country-Code    Italy
.JE        Country-Code    Jersey
.JM        Country-Code    Jamaica
.JO        Country-Code    Jordan
.JP        Country-Code    Japan
.KE        Country-Code    Kenya
.KG        Country-Code    Kyrgyzstan
.KH        Country-Code    Cambodia
.KI        Country-Code    Kiribati
.KM        Country-Code    Comoros
.KN        Country-Code    Saint Kitts and Nevis
.KP        Country-Code    Korea, Democratic People’s Republic of
.KR        Country-Code    Korea, Republic of
.KW        Country-Code    Kuwait
.KY        Country-Code    Cayman Islands
.KZ        Country-Code    Kazakhstan
.LA        Country-Code    Lao People’s Democratic Republic
.LB        Country-Code    Lebanon
.LC        Country-Code    Saint Lucia
.LI        Country-Code    Liechtenstein
.LK        Country-Code    Sri Lanka
.LR        Country-Code    Liberia
.LS        Country-Code    Lesotho
.LT        Country-Code    Lithuania
.LU        Country-Code    Luxembourg
.LV        Country-Code    Latvia
.LY        Country-Code    Libyan Arab Jamahiriya
.MA        Country-Code    Morocco
.MC        Country-Code    Monaco
.MD        Country-Code    Moldova, Republic of
.ME        Country-Code    Montenegro
.MF        Country-Code    Saint Martin
.MG        Country-Code    Madagascar
.MH        Country-Code    Marshall Islands
.MK        Country-Code    Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic of
.ML        Country-Code    Mali
.MM        Country-Code    Myanmar
.MN        Country-Code    Mongolia
.MO        Country-Code    Macao
.MP        Country-Code    Northern Mariana Islands
.MQ        Country-Code    Martinique
.MR        Country-Code    Mauritania
.MS        Country-Code    Montserrat
.MT        Country-Code    Malta
.MU        Country-Code    Mauritius
.MV        Country-Code    Maldives
.MW        Country-Code    Malawi
.MX        Country-Code    Mexico
.MY        Country-Code    Malaysia
.MZ        Country-Code    Mozambique
.NA        Country-Code    Namibia
.NC        Country-Code    New Caledonia
.NE        Country-Code    Niger
.NF        Country-Code    Norfolk Island
.NG        Country-Code    Nigeria
.NI        Country-Code    Nicaragua
.NL        Country-Code    Netherlands
.NO        Country-Code    Norway
.NP        Country-Code    Nepal
.NR        Country-Code    Nauru
.NU        Country-Code    Niue
.NZ        Country-Code    New Zealand
.OM        Country-Code    Oman
.PA        Country-Code    Panama
.PE        Country-Code    Peru
.PF        Country-Code    French Polynesia
.PG        Country-Code    Papua New Guinea
.PH        Country-Code    Philippines
.PK        Country-Code    Pakistan
.PL        Country-Code    Poland
.PM        Country-Code    Saint Pierre and Miquelon
.PN        Country-Code    Pitcairn
.PR        Country-Code    Puerto Rico
.PS        Country-Code    Palestinian Territory, Occupied
.PT        Country-Code    Portugal
.PW        Country-Code    Palau
.PY        Country-Code    Paraguay
.QA        Country-Code    Qatar
.RE        Country-Code    Reunion
.RO        Country-Code    Romania
.RS        Country-Code    Serbia
.RU        Country-Code    Russian Federation
.RW        Country-Code    Rwanda
.SA        Country-Code    Saudi Arabia
.SB        Country-Code    Solomon Islands
.SC        Country-Code    Seychelles
.SD        Country-Code    Sudan
.SE        Country-Code    Sweden
.SG        Country-Code    Singapore
.SH        Country-Code    Saint Helena
.SI        Country-Code    Slovenia
.SJ        Country-Code    Svalbard and Jan Mayen
.SK        Country-Code    Slovakia
.SL        Country-Code    Sierra Leone
.SM        Country-Code    San Marino
.SN        Country-Code    Senegal
.SO        Country-Code    Somalia
.SR        Country-Code    Suriname
.ST        Country-Code    Sao Tome and Principe
.SU        Country-Code    Soviet Union (being phased out)
.SV        Country-Code    El Salvador
.SY        Country-Code    Syrian Arab Republic
.SZ        Country-Code    Swaziland
.TC        Country-Code    Turks and Caicos Islands
.TD        Country-Code    Chad
.TF        Country-Code    French Southern Territories
.TG        Country-Code    Togo
.TH        Country-Code    Thailand
.TJ        Country-Code    Tajikistan
.TK        Country-Code    Tokelau
.TL        Country-Code    Timor
.TM        Country-Code    Turkmenistan
.TN        Country-Code    Tunisia
.TO        Country-Code    Tonga
.TP        Country-Code    Portuguese Timor (being phased out)
.TR        Country-Code    Turkey
.TT        Country-Code    Trinidad and Tobago
.TV        Country-Code    Tuvalu
.TW        Country-Code    Taiwan
.TZ        Country-Code    Tanzania, United Republic of
.UA        Country-Code    Ukraine
.UG        Country-Code    Uganda
.UK        Country-Code    United Kingdom
.UM        Country-Code    United States Minor Outlying Islands
.US        Country-Code    United States
.UY        Country-Code    Uruguay
.UZ        Country-Code    Uzbekistan
.VA        Country-Code    Holy See (Vatican City State)
.VC        Country-Code    Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
.VE        Country-Code    Venezuela, Bolivarian Republic of
.VG        Country-Code    Virgin Islands, British
.VI        Country-Code    Virgin Islands, U.S.
.VN        Country-Code    Viet Nam
.VU        Country-Code    Vanuatu
.WF        Country-Code    Wallis and Futuna
.WS        Country-Code    Samoa
.YE        Country-Code    Yemen
.YT        Country-Code    Mayotte
.YU        Country-Code    Yugoslavia (being phased out)
.ZA        Country-Code    South Africa
.ZM        Country-Code    Zambia
.ZW        Country-Code    Zimbabwe

(IDNs represented as “.IDNTLD”; see ICANN site for actual representations). They look like these:

idn-tlds

.IDNTLD-Ar-Arab    Test Test:Ar-Arab
.IDNTLD-EL-Grek    Test Test:El-Grek
.IDNTLD-FA-Arab    Test Test:Fa-Arab
.IDNTLD-Hi-Deva    Test Test:Hi-Deva
.IDNTLD-JA-Kana    Test Test:Ja-Kana
.IDNTLD-KO-Hang    Test Test:Ko-Hang
.IDNTLD-RU-Cyrl    Test Test:Ru-Cyrl
.IDNTLD-TA-Taml    Test Test:Ta-Taml
.IDNTLD-YI-Hebr    Test Test:Yi-Hebr
.IDNTLD-ZH-Hans    Test Test:Zh-Hans
.IDNTLD-ZH-Hant    Test Test:Zh-Hant

AFRINIC        Reserved Name
ALAC        Reserved Name
APNIC        Reserved Name
ARIN        Reserved Name
ASO        Reserved Name
CCNSO        Reserved Name
EXAMPLE*    Reserved Name *Including various translations of “example”
GAC        Reserved Name
GNSO        Reserved Name
GTLD-SERVERS    Reserved Name
IAB        Reserved Name
IANA        Reserved Name
IANA-SERVERS    Reserved Name
ICANN        Reserved Name
IESG        Reserved Name
IETF        Reserved Name
INTERNIC    Reserved Name
INVALID        Reserved Name
IRTF        Reserved Name
ISTF        Reserved Name
LACNIC        Reserved Name
LOCAL        Reserved Name
LOCALHOST    Reserved Name
NIC        Reserved Name
NRO        Reserved Name
RFC-EDITOR    Reserved Name
RIPE        Reserved Name
ROOT-SERVERS    Reserved Name
RSSAC        Reserved Name
SSAC        Reserved Name
TEST*        Reserved Name *Including various translations of “test”
TLD        Reserved Name
WHOIS        Reserved Name
WWW        Reserved Name

Sources at time of writing:

  • https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ga.html
  • http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=gm
  • http://www.icann.org
Posted in Domain Names, ICANN, New Top Level Domains, Registrars, Registries | Comments Off on What Can You NOT Get in a New TLD?